Monuments Going Up in Smoke
Let’s talk wildfire, or more specifically, let’s talk about the effects on boundary monuments by wildfire. Even more specifically, let’s talk about heavy equipment making fire breaks before the fires start and heavy equipment scooping up the remains of devastated properties after the wildfire has gone through, and how those two activities can completely destroy critical survey monuments for a parcel, for a neighborhood, or for an entire community.
Why this is relevant to me: Having worked for 3 years in the Town of Paradise after the deadly Camp Fire, I can attest to the fact that the wholesale use of loaders and dozers to clean up in the aftermath is where the monuments were lost, not in the fire itself. My firm recovered some 5500 monuments before cleanup while working with a utility company to restore electricity to Paradise, neighborhood by neighborhood. In looking at the law in California, it appeared we were on the hook for 5,500 corner records documenting the position and character of each monument. As a matter of efficiency and of giving the most useful tool to the surveying community, we chose not to prepare corner records and instead filed a 64-sheet record of survey documenting these monuments with a control diagram, coordinates, and descriptions, before they were lost during the protracted rebuilding process. Strangely, perhaps, the Butte County Surveyor was not involved in any way in these activities. While they were very grateful to receive the survey, it can easily be argued that a similar effort could and should have been made under their direction as an immediate reaction to the conflagration. But there is no plan or guidelines for this kind of situation and any county surveyor would need to think outside the box in such circumstances.
In 2021, in the aftermath of the North Complex Fire, Butte County did release contracts for surveyors to establish and mark out the right of way lines for 40 miles of rural highways before tree felling could commence. The contracts were not directly targeting monument preservation but it would not be possible to reestablish these rights of way without recovering numerous monuments and so it was a happy by-product. In my firm’s ten-mile stretch, we recovered well over a hundred section corners, quarter corners, and property corners. We filed nine records of the survey to document the results.
In 2022 El Dorado County, in the aftermath of the Caldor Fire, issued a contract to our firm to go into the community of Grizzly Flats, while the embers were still hot and before tree falling and dozing began, to establish a permanent control network and recover as many monuments as we could in two weeks. In the absence of any funding mechanism for the work, including FEMA disaster relief, the El Dorado County Surveyor spent discretionary funds out of his department’s account to get this done. And we donated some of our time and effort for the good of the community. We recovered about 450 monuments before FEMA blocked us from getting into the danger areas, and we filed an 18-sheet record survey showing the network and the monuments. This operation should serve as a solid example of how a county can react after a catastrophe.
Why this is relevant to you: Last year Oregon and Washington started generating wildfires in a way that was very reminiscent of California, and just this spring huge wildfires raged across Canada from British Columbia to Quebec. Wildfires are not the only disasters which this discussion is relevant. Hurricanes, tornadoes, catastrophic flooding, landslides, earthquakes, and volcanoes (in Hawaii, primarily) can all have dramatically deleterious effects on boundary monuments, as well. Taken all together, there is precious little of the country where monuments are not subject to assault by natural forces.
We cannot afford to think of these events as occasional, or as being limited to one region of the country, that they ‘can’t happen here.’ These days, natural disasters seem to have become a regular part of our lives, across the continent. Cities and counties will need to accept this new reality and start behaving in such a way that disaster prevention and disaster recovery become organized operations and not haphazard responses. Surveyors need to raise the awareness level of these agencies as to the critical nature of monuments concerning land boundaries and the legal requirements to preserve or perpetuate them. And if the area you practice in does not have a legal requirement to preserve monuments, maybe your state society’s legislative committee needs to take this up, and soon.
Hereabouts, a longtime practicing California Land Surveyor from the Central Valley has taken this issue to heart. Michael Quartaroli has spent countless hours preparing and promoting a very succinct white paper on the topic of wildfire and monument preservation. To date, he has been a lone voice in the wilderness. California has strong regulations regarding monument preservation, but they were written in the context of construction and development activities and make no specific mention of the surveyors’ (or agencies,’ or contractors’) responsibility in the face of disaster prevention work, such as dozing wholesale fire breaks or buttressing slopes in danger of failure. While the law is clear enough that anyone should be able to see that conserving monuments must be an unavoidable part of any such operation, that fact may not be well-known or understood in offices beyond that of the County Surveyor. As urgent as disaster prevention policy is concerning monuments, it is even more urgent to establish a policy regarding disaster recovery. In all cases, the local agency should be prepared to dispatch surveyors in to recover monuments before clean-up commences. Is there a funding mechanism for this? Probably not. But if that is true then the agencies should work on establishing one. Mike’s paper lays out responsibilities and strategies for monument preservation in fire country very well and could serve as a blueprint for how to deal with this issue, whether for fires or any natural disaster, far beyond the borders of California. It can be obtained by emailing firstname.lastname@example.org. I hope you will all download and review it and start a conversation about it at your local chapter!!